Welcome to Toast Coffeehouse
Toast Coffeehouse, located in Bay Shore, NY, is a vibrant spot offering a wide range of delectable waffles, refreshing juice options, and hearty brunch choices. Known for its efficient service and innovative virtual waiting list system, guests can enjoy a seamless dining experience. The menu boasts unique dishes like the Tres Leche Eggnog French Toast and savory Tennessee Chicken and Waffles. With a cozy atmosphere and generous portions, Toast Coffeehouse is the perfect place for a satisfying breakfast or brunch. The drink specials, including mimosa flights and specialty coffee drinks, add an extra flair to the dining experience. My visits have always been delightful, and I look forward to returning for more culinary delights.
- 9 S Park Ave Bay Shore, NY 117069 S Park Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706 Hotline: (631) 647-9560
Welcome to Toast Coffeehouse, a delightful dining haven nestled at 9 S Park Ave, Bay Shore, NY. This bustling establishment has quickly become a favorite for brunch enthusiasts, offering an inviting atmosphere that makes every visit a memorable experience. The cozy décor, combined with ample parking, sets the stage for a relaxing meal with friends or family.
At Toast Coffeehouse, breakfast isn't just a meal—it's a celebration. The menu boasts a curated selection of mouthwatering dishes, each expertly crafted to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you're craving their Splendid Benedict, featuring perfectly poached organic eggs and a delectable avocado fritter, or the rich and savory Corned Beef Hash & Eggs, there's something here for everyone. The innovative Tennessee Chicken and Waffles combines flaky waffles with a spicy twist, ensuring a harmonious balance of flavors that is both bold and comforting.
And let's not forget their enticing drink menu! Choose from expertly crafted smoothies like the Strawberry Banana or try one of their tempting margaritas, such as the Morning Glorious—perfect for those looking to elevate their brunch experience. The mimosa flight is especially popular, allowing guests to sample a variety of bubbly concoctions while soaking in the lively atmosphere.
The rave reviews speak volumes about Toast Coffeehouse's commitment to excellence. Customers like Steph T. and Tonya B. emphasize not only the quality of the food but also the attentive and friendly service. It's clear that the staff goes above and beyond, making each visit feel personalized and warm. From the thoughtful hostess to the knowledgeable servers, it’s the genuine hospitality that keeps guests returning for more.
In summation, if you're searching for a brunch spot that combines exuberant flavors, delightful ambiance, and outstanding service, look no further than Toast Coffeehouse. So gather your friends and family, and prepare to indulge in a culinary journey that is sure to leave you eagerly anticipating your next visit.

I've been to a few brunch places on LI and this is by far the best. First of all, service is quick. They have a virtual waiting list, which is awesome because you don't have to wait in person. It tells you exactly how many people are before you. You can arrive on time and your table is waiting. Chef's kiss Second of all, drinks are on point they have mimosa flights. Third, the place is decorated nicely and there are parking lots on both sides of the restaurant. Fourth, the food is excellent. Portions are large. I will be returning! Oh, and all the servers are so nice and friendly. Can't go wrong coming here! check it out!

It's been a while since my husband and I visited Toast Coffeehouse but we are so happy we stopped in. The food was so good. We ended up getting the Avocado Skillet, Dig Me Omelette, Tres Leches Egg Nog French Toast with Blueberry Lemonades. The French Toast was more like a bread pudding in texture, thick but not overly sweet. The flavors melded well together. It was definitely worth trying out. The Skillet and Omelette were well seasoned. The breakfast potatoes were a little salty for us, so if you have any salt sensitivities please be aware of this. Our waitress was very pleasant and professional and assisted us in better understanding the menu options. She was kind. The environment was how we remembered a bit noisy but that can happen when everyone is enjoying their food. We'll absolutely visit again in the near future.

My boyfriend has been wanting us to come here and I am so glad we finally made it. Upon walking in we added our names to the list there was a wait 45 min. but it did move quickly. (( ** Please note you are able to call ahead this may save you sometime** )) They had a breast cancer table displayed which of course we supported and brought some bracelets. The hostess Elena was so kind I mean she really went above and beyond. While we were waiting she went over the menu with us prior to us being seated gave us some good recommendations. Which I ended up enjoying she even came over to us after our meal and asked us what we thought. I have been dining out for years and I have never experienced a hostess being this genuine and it was refreshing and she made us feel so welcomed. She also gave us a little insite about this location and the others. I really apppreciated her kindness and I'm so happy that this is the way we were greeted! Matt was our server he was good but of course busy. For drinks we got a vanilla chai tea latte which was delicious and given in a unique skull mug. I loved the fact that everyone had a different mug the ones that I did see were beautiful. I ordered the fall iced coffee flight which did have some good options pumpkin pie, apple cider donut, chocolate covered pretzel and caramel waffle. It can be slightly overwhelming but it was overall good and later I ordered the mimosa flight that was also good they had many flavors I just allowed my server to pick for me. To start off I ordered the avocado toast with an over easy egg which was delicious it comes with fries so this is can absolutely be a main but we came to try many items so we couldn't stop here. I would absolutely get this over and over again! My daughter got a homemade chicken burger and added bacon she enjoyed it. It was a great size burger that was also accompanied by fries and a pickle. For myself I ordered the Tennessee chicken and waffles which were the spicier option. It was covered with peppers and onions now it's not very spicy but there is good flavor. They gave a apple jam on the side that I didn't bother using it didn't add anything to the dish for me. Great portion to share. My boyfriend got the Banana walnut pancakes with a ham steak which ultimately is his go to whenever we go out for breakfast. The pancakes were filled nicely and they even added a little extra to the top. I thought they were good. He also got the "Dig me" omelet which we shared and I thought it was good he added a biscuit to it instead of bread and hot home fries which were seasoned well.

Ive been to Toast a few times now, and they never disappoint! I would suggest going early. I went around 9:30 and was seated immediately, and we were a party of 5. I ordered a salted caramel latte; it was so good! For food, I went with the Tennessee chicken and waffles. It was delicious. I never had sweet potato waffles before. Our waitress was also very sweet and attentive. They are always so busy, and we did not feel rushed at all. I will always keep coming back here.

Loved the pace, very rustic with a good vibe, the service was very good, and the food was great, we did go there for brunch, all the dishes were tasty and the portions were good. We will probably return for more choices.

Came back to toast with some good friends who was visiting. Had a huge feast before driving over to Montauk - Mocha Latte - Steak & Eggs with home fries and biscuit - Shared the original French toast with my girlfriend - Banana French toast - Biscuits and gravy - Gluten free Pancakes, home fries, bacon and over easy eggs - Omelet with whole wheat bread, home fries Huge portion size even for their Lattes If you join their rewards program you get 2.50 off from your bill.

Great breakfast/ brunch / lunch place. Good service, excellent food and big portions. We had the iced coffee flights which were fantastic and so fun! They even have oat milk if needed. They had many vegetarian options but I have to say, they do seem to have some form of meat in many many items, more than usual I think. Would be great if they could have some impossible burger or beyond meat options as well. People next to us had amazing looking watermelon mimosas!! There is generally a line to get in, but they are very organized. , and you can go on line and get on their waiting list, which moves quickly and they are on top of. There is a parking lot, but it was full. We did find a space on the street. They gave me a short stack of birthday sprinkles pancakes , on the house. Fun.